Friday, July 27, 2012

Penn State, Justice, and Sports

I grew up watching college football.  Sometimes when I am just sitting and thinking, my mind will drift back to Saturday afternoons with my father and brother. We would sit on the couch, drink soda, eat chips, and watch the SEC or the Big Ten or whatever else was on. It did not matter who was playing. It was football and we loved it. We would all go out and throw the football in the backyard during halftime. There is a glow to those days for me. I loved them and still do.

But times have changed. Or maybe I have changed. Or maybe when you are twelve NCAA sanctions just do not matter.  Whatever the case, the world of sports in general and college sports in particular has been rocked by scandal after scandal over the last ten years. Here are few: Jim Tressel removed at Ohio State, The New Orleans Saints paying players to injure other players, numerous examples of players being paid to play in college, the steroids scandal in MLB, the New England Patriots taping other teams practices, etc. etc.

Besides these things you have many examples of behavior that is not illegal, but sinful. For example, Lebron James had a one hour special on where he was going when he left Cleveland for Miami. The Bible has a word for that; pride.  Lane Kiffin, along with numerous other coaches, make promises to schools and recruits and then break those promises for more money. They are whores who go to the john who will give them the most money.  We could go on and on . Sports, like America in general, bows before the idols of money, power, and pleasure. Maybe this has always been the case, but it seems worse now.

But there is nothing comparable, at least in my memory, to the Jerry Sandusky scandal at Penn State. If you do not know what happened here is a brief rundown.  Jerry Sandusky, a coach at Penn State University, sexually abused boys since at least 1994. This abuse was covered up by three prominent Penn State officials, including Coach Joe Paterno. Numerous others were probably involved in the cover up as well.  Jerry Sandusky has been convicted of 43 counts of sexual abuse. Joe Paterno is dead. Several other Penn State officials have resigned.

This past Monday the NCAA gave Penn State $60 million in fines, cut their scholarships significantly, put them on five years probation, and had them vacate all wins from 1998-2011. It is also apparent that the victims are going to sue Penn State for millions of dollars. This is a perfect example of non-justice. What happens in situations like this is the innocent are made to suffer for the crimes of others. There are several points I want to make.

First, a friend of mine has said that corporations do not make decisions. People do. This is true. Penn State the school cannot be blamed. The men who committed the crimes and covered up the crimes are the ones who should be tried and convicted. We love to do this in our culture. Let's blame the media. Let's blame the bank. Let's blame the government in general. The Scriptures teach that people are to blame. That does not mean institutions cannot be corrupt. They can be. But  they are corrupt because corrupt men run the show.

Second, the NCAA has just caused thousands of innocent people, students, teachers, athletes, residents of the community to suffer for crimes they had nothing to do with, did not know about, and could not stop. In the name of justice they have condemned the innocent. The Scriptures explicitly forbid this. The NCAA should have encouraged Penn State to come up with some way of helping the victims. One person suggested a portion of proceeds from tickets should go to a fund for the victims. There are other things Penn State could have done. But the NCAA has guaranteed that despite one key player dead, another in jail, and numerous others disgraced this crime will live on and on. Penn State cannot put this behind them. It is hard not to view this as revenge instead of justice.

Third, the NCAA is supposed to police illegal activities involving football.  They have stepped outside of their jurisdiction by dealing with criminal activity. Why? There was political pressure for the NCAA to "do something."  Instead of having a backbone and saying that this did not involve them, they bent to the pressure.  What is odd, is that the NCAA often refuses to act when there are illegal football activities. For them to act here is absurd. Here are couple of articles that make that point; Stewart Mandel, Tim Keown and Andy Staples. It is odd that NCAA refuses to punish where it has jurisdiction and punishes where it has none.

Fourth, what Jerry Sandusky did and the cover up by Penn State officials was wicked. Sandusky deserves to be executed for his crimes. Joe Paterno is dead and his memory deserves to be effaced.  Recently Penn State removed a statue of him. That was the right thing to do. He knowingly covered up a wicked act. He does not deserve praise or honor. Nothing in this article should be taken as condoning the crimes committed or saying the men deserved an easy sentence. But apparently Sandusky going to prison and Paterno being disgraced is not enough. Someone else must pay.  And that someone is all the people at Penn State.

Finally, I love sports. I love playing football and basketball. I love a perfect fade route for a touchdown, a home run in the bottom of the ninth, a slam dunk that thunders throughout the gym, or a breakaway goal for a score.  But sports like the rest of America is filled with godless men and women who use their authority, power, and fame to puff up themselves and destroy those around them.  Yes, there are some good men in sports. Men whose use their job to serve others instead of themselves. But sports, like the rest of America, is rotting from the inside out. The answer, as always, is Christ. Legislation will not keep what happened at Penn State from happening again. Only repentance can solve our problems.


Anonymous said...

The NCAA sanctions impose a consequence (or penalty) for a school culture in which individuals became so revered, powerful, and independant that these transgressions could be hidden. To some degree, that culture spans leadership, players, donors, and fans. The reality and gravity of this consequence gives incentive for all schools to be proactive in oversight and control of their cultures and employees.

This is exactly like a penalty in the game of football. If an individual defender commits pass interference, or a low hit, the other team is robbed of a scoring opportunity or an individual player may be physically injured. There is no way for this wrong to be made right. The quarterback's beautiful pass cannot be recreated, the injured cannot be made whole. The only response, among peer humans, is to impose a penalty, not only on the individual, but also on the entire team as an incentive for the team to train their players not to commit this offence.

Unfortunately, in the modern culture of sport, it is taught from a young age, and even celebrated as good strategy, that it is OK to commit an offence as long as you either don't get caught or are ready to accept the penalty. It's ok to break the rules as long as the final analysis works in your favor. (You should intentionally foul a player if you're one point down and the clock is ticking... interfere with a pass if it could mean the championship...) The concepts of right and wrong and honorable fair play have been replaced with an empty calculus of competetive advantage. As a result, the penalties must grow progressively more extreme to keep up with the ever increasing money, power, and fame on the other side of the equation.

Peter Jones said...

Anonymous, thanks for the comment. A couple of thoughts. If we are going to use the "culture" argument, the NCAA is just as guilty as Penn State. They puff up coaches, players, and teams all the time. They create the environment, as much as Penn State. But also who is being punished? It is the whole city being fined for the crimes of its mayor. Sure there people who went along with him. But there were way more innocents.

I agree with your comment about sport's culture in general. But that does not give us the right to punish those who had no hand in the crime. With Grace, Peter Jones

Let the saints be joyful in glory, let them sing aloud on their beds, let the high praises of God be in their mouth, and a two edged sword in their hand, to execute vengeance on the nations, and punishments on the peoples; to bind the kings with chains and their nobles with fetters of iron. Psalm 149:5-8